Hyundai i30 Fastback vs Mazda Three Fastback
In actual fact, for those who’re after a automobile of this sort there are actually solely two choices: the brand new Hyundai i30 Fastback (which is definitely a five-door) and Mazda’s Three Fastback, at the very least till the Honda Civic four-door arrives later within the yr.
• Finest household vehicles to purchase
It’s honest to say that the i30 and three Fastbacks are area of interest decisions and that the common vehicles higher cater for UK patrons’ tastes. However some folks will desire what these fashions provide.
Nonetheless, there’s little doubt that these two vehicles tick lots of the similar bins on a possible purchasing listing, so which is the higher choose?
|Mannequin:||Hyundai i30 Fastback 1.Zero T-GDi Premium||Mazda Three Fastback 2.Zero Sport Nav|
|Engine:||1.0-litre 3cyl turbo petrol||2.0-litre 4cyl petrol|
|Transmission:||Six-speed handbook, front-wheel drive||Six-speed handbook, front-wheel drive|
|0-60mph/prime pace:||10.Three seconds/117mph||10.Zero seconds/123mph|
|Check financial system:||35.6mpg||36.9mpg|
|Choices:||Metallic paint (£585)||Metallic paint (£670), mild stone leather-based trim (£1,200)|
Hyundai i30 Fastback
For: Extra fascinating design than common hatchback model, nice infotainment system, snug
Towards: Not a lot enjoyable to drive, costlier than the hatch
Having established itself as a mainstream model, Hyundai took an enormous step by designing, growing and testing its new i30 in Europe, for European patrons. That features the Fastback model, even when it’s not fairly as fashionable as its common hatchback sibling.
The present i30 vary hints at Hyundai’s mainstream gross sales ambitions with its restrained look, and it’s an identical story inside, the place the i30 clearly takes cues from the likes of the Volkswagen Golf. It doesn’t fairly pull that off, although, and whereas high quality is sweet, the design is obvious; the Mazda’s inside is extra fascinating.
• New Hyundai i30 Fastback 2018 assessment
This conservative really feel continues underneath the pores and skin, as a result of the i30 Fastback is quiet and calm on the transfer. At idle the thrum from the 1.0-litre three-cylinder engine is noisier than the sleek 2.0-litre four-cylinder within the Mazda, however when you get above 30mph the Hyundai is totally on par with its rival by way of refinement.
With 118bhp and 171Nm of torque, the unit serves up respectable efficiency, and though the automobile was slightly slower than the Mazda from 0-60mph on the monitor, in our in-gear assessments that higher characterize real-world use it had the sting.
From 50-70mph in sixth it was over 4 and a half seconds quicker than the three, which helps out quite a bit on the motorway; you’ll want to keep up momentum extra fastidiously within the Mazda, or change all the way down to speed up.
The Hyundai was quicker in all of our in-gear assessments, however it did path its rival by almost a second masking 30-70mph by way of the gears.
What’s extra essential with these fashions is trip high quality, although, and whereas the i30 offers effectively with tough roads up to a degree, the suspension begins to battle on uneven surfaces and there’s a extra noticeable quantity of physique motion than in its rival right here. The i30 Fastback is a snug motorway cruiser, nevertheless.
Regardless of trip consolation being barely worse than the Mazda’s, the i30 can be fairly uninteresting to drive. There’s loads of grip, however the numb steering takes away out of your enjoyment as a driver and physique roll in corners is extra intrusive than within the Mazda.
The six-speed gearbox and thrummy three-cylinder engine go some solution to including a little bit of driver attraction, however it could actually’t match the sweet-handling Mazda Three Fastback right here. It’s rather more suited to a relaxed driving model, however its rival can accommodate that simply as effectively, whereas additionally being extra enjoyable and interesting.
- • Design: Dashboard design in Hyundai is practical and helpful, however there’s little visible curiosity
- • Connectivity: You get Apple CarPlay and Android Auto as customary on the i30, and the show works very effectively with the smartphone-based methods
- • Supplies: High quality is sweet, however finishes aren’t as tactile as Mazda’s. Construct high quality trails as effectively
Mazda Three Fastback
For: Nice driving expertise, pretty handbook gearchange, snug trip
Towards: Dated infotainment system, slower in-gear efficiency than rival
The Mazda Three Fastback is predicated on the common 3, however with its rear-end redesign it’s a real saloon. Consequently, the boot is deeper and it affords more room than in the usual hatch.
Nonetheless, it does influence practicality slightly in different methods as a result of for most individuals the hatch model’s simpler entry will likely be preferable – and even the i30 Fastback makes use of a hatchback boot to enhance entry to the load bay.
• Mazda Three in-depth assessment
Mazda affords a restricted vary of three Fastbacks, with solely two trim ranges and one engine: this 118bhp 2.0-litre petrol. The excellent news is that the engine is a spotlight of the driving expertise.
With no turbocharger, the naturally aspirated unit is clean and really satisfying to make use of. You’ll must carry on prime of your gearchanges so as to keep within the energy band, however that’s no hardship as a result of the handbook gearbox within the Three Fastback is among the finest in any automobile, with a pleasant, exact and mechanical-feeling shift.
In our in-gear assessments the Mazda fell behind barely, as a result of it doesn’t have the identical low-down torque because the turbo engine within the i30. It took the Mazda 11.four seconds to cowl 50-70mph in fifth, whereas the i30 was a complete second quicker, recording a time of 10.four seconds. The three was additionally slower in third and fourth from 30-50mph.
Whereas the petrol engines in each vehicles ship little greater than ample efficiency, their attraction is extra centered on their refinement.
The Mazda is the smoother of the 2, and specifically is extra hushed at motorway speeds. It should additionally attraction extra for eager drivers regardless of a efficiency deficit, as a result of it’s extra enjoyable to rev.
Trip consolation is one other extremely essential issue for these two fashions, and the Mazda has the sting over the i30 right here. It rides easily over bumps and potholes, each at pace and round city. There’s not quite a bit in it – each vehicles are greater than snug sufficient – however the Mazda’s higher damping places it forward right here.
It’s additionally considerably extra composed in corners than its rival, and is genuinely enjoyable to drive. The well-weighted controls, balanced chassis and satisfying powertrain imply the three is partaking in any respect speeds in just about all environments. The Mazda’s good driving place can be a match for the expertise.
One other issue that units the three aside right here is its high-quality inside. It doesn’t look fairly as fashionable as many hatchback rivals’, however subsequent to the Hyundai the Mazda’s dashboard is manufactured from extra upmarket supplies and feels very stable.
- • Infotainment: Central touchscreen affords nav, and may very well be sharper, however it’s simple sufficient to make use of and in addition responds rapidly to inputs by way of centre console dial
- • Dashboard: Excessive-quality supplies which can be nice to the touch imply Mazda feels extra upmarket
- • Seats: Driving place within the Three is excellent, providing spectacular consolation, help and visibility
First place: Mazda Three Fastback
The three Fastback isn’t as convincing because the hatch model, nor many household fashions, however it’s your best option on this class of two (for now). It’s higher to drive, extra snug, cheaper and has a greater inside than the Hyundai, so it takes the win on this face to face.
Second place: Hyundai i30 Fastback
The i30 Fastback has no main flaws, however its uninteresting driving expertise and cabin cease it profitable right here. Whereas it’s a bit roomier than the three, this isn’t sufficient to steal a victory; the marginally fidgety trip signifies that though there’s more room, passengers received’t be as snug.